COVID-19 Research, January 2021

On Airborne Virus Transmission in Confined Spaces

Talib Dbouk and Dimitris Drikakis, University of Nicosia. Published in Physics of Fluids on 26 January 2021.

The Study

The impact of air ventilation systems on airborne virus transmission, and aerosols in general, in confined spaces, is not yet understood.

The recent pandemic has made it crucial to understand the limitations of ventilation systems regarding virus transmission.

Let us consider an elevator as a prototypical example of a confined space and show how ventilation designs alone, regardless of cooling or heating, contribute to the airborne virus transmission.

In this study, we investigated air circulation effects inside an elevator by employing advanced multiphase computational fluid dynamics. We were interested in the performance of an air purifier installed in an elevator for reducing airborne virus transmission.

For the above reasons, we have investigated three different flow scenarios regarding the position and operation of inlets and outlets inside the elevator, and a fourth scenario that includes the operation of the air purifier.

Interestingly, we found that the position of the inlets and outlets significantly influences the flow circulation and droplet dispersion. More importantly, we found that an air purifier installed inside an elevator does not eliminate airborne virus transmission.

Figure 1: The geometry shows the different inlets and outlets (with 3 cm openings width) in an elevator.
Figure 1: The geometry shows the different inlets and outlets (with 3 cm openings width) in an elevator. A subject is standing in the elevator’s cabin such that the subject’s mouth as a coughing source is positioned at x = 0 m, y= 0.41 m, z = 1.6 m. An air purifier (sanitizer) is also attached to the wall at about 1.9 m above the elevator’s cabin’s ground. The air purifier has an air intake (outlet 4) and air exhaust (inlet 4) for air circulation at ≈60 m3 /h. At the right sides (blue images with black arrows) is an example of air circulation for a specific scenario A showing the velocity magnitude at different planes. The environment is at 20 °C and 50% relative humidity. For this scenario D conditions, see Dbouk and Drikakis, Physics of Fluids, 33, 011905, (2021).
Figure 2: Local dispersion of contaminated saliva droplets inside an elevator’s cabin due to the presence of an air purifier.
Figure 2: Local dispersion of contaminated saliva droplets inside an elevator’s cabin due to the presence of an air purifier. Top column: front view. Middle column: top view. Bottom column: side view. Contaminated saliva droplets are illustrated in black after being scaled by a factor of about 250 for their actual size. Subject position 2 corresponds to a person standing in the elevator’s cabin such that her/his mouth as a coughing source is positioned at x = 0 m, y = 0.675 m, z = 1.6 m. For this scenario D conditions, see Dbouk and Drikakis, Physics of Fluids, 33, 011905, (2021).

Dbouk, T. and Drikakis, D. On airborne virus transmission in elevators and confined spaces. Physics of Fluids 33, 011905 (2021), published online 26 January 2021. doi.org/10.1063/5.0038180

What Does This Mean?

In confined spaces such as an elevator, the placement of ventilation inlets and outlets significantly influences the flow circulation and droplet dispersion. Without an air purifier, the case of a single inlet and outlet exhibits the least droplet dispersion. The subject’s position inside the cabin also influences the flow circulation and droplet spread. The air purifier reduces the droplet dispersion but will not eliminate it. The air intake integrated inside the purifier equipment induces flow circulation that can add to the contaminated saliva droplets in the cabin. The time required for droplets reaching the elevator floor could be larger than the time necessary to deactivate the virus by other means such as UV radiation. Thus, the success of air purifiers lies in addressing the issue mentioned above. The present study’s results are pertinent to any confined spaces, including small rooms in residential or commercial facilities, car parks, shops, and an aircraft cabin, submarines, and spacecraft.

The broader implications of the present findings are that health and safety authorities must revise guidelines accordingly by considering the flow circulation and droplet dispersion effects from air purifiers and sanitisers in confined spaces. The design of future ventilation and purification systems should reduce airborne virus transmission through minimisation of droplet dispersion.

Videos

The simulations published with the paper. Each opens as a video file in the browser.

  • Video 1 (MP4): Contaminated saliva droplets dispersion inside an elevator’s cabin due to an operating air purifier: The air purifier induces local air circulations represented by the velocity contours isosurfaces. The contaminated saliva droplets are illustrated in black dots.

UNIC’s COVID-19 Response

During the pandemic, University of Nicosia faculty across a range of academic disciplines worked on research and analysis, and served in scientific and public policy roles supporting the COVID-19 response.

The university’s other COVID-19 research is gathered on COVID-19 Research.

Contact Information

For more information about this study, contact Professor Dimitris Drikakis at drikakis.d@unic.ac.cy.