COVID-19 Research

On Coughing and Airborne Droplet Transmission to Humans

Talib Dbouk and Dimitris Drikakis, University of Nicosia. Published in Physics of Fluids on 19 May 2020.

The Study

The recent COVID-19 pandemic prompted the need for deeper understanding of the transport of fluids and droplets emanating from our respiratory tracts when we cough, sneeze, speak or breathe. The droplets transport will influence the spread of coronavirus and determine the implementation of guidelines about social distancing, mask wearing, crowded gatherings, as well as everyday practices of social behaviour in private, public and business environments.

The results of our research showed that in open spaces, airborne droplets carriers can travel significantly further than the 2 metres recommended distance due to the wind speed. The issues arising from the past and recent pandemic require a holistic approach to elucidate the open scientific questions and address the practical challenges. Such an approach would require closer interaction between bio-medicine, engineering fluid physics, and social sciences.

Figure 1: Saliva droplet cloud kinematics show the diameter of the droplets resulting from a human cough.
Figure 1: Saliva droplet cloud kinematics show the diameter of the droplets resulting from a human cough. Larger droplets settle more rapidly than smaller ones due to gravitational forces. The wind speed is approximately 0 km/h. The total mass of ejected saliva is 7.7 mg, with 1008 total number of droplets. The environment is at ambient temperature, pressure, and relative humidity of 20 oC, 1 atm, and 50%, respectively, with the ground temperature at 15 oC. The droplets in the figure have been scaled up for visualisation purposes.
Figure 2: A human cough: saliva droplet’s disease-carrier particles emanating from coughing do not travel more than 2 m in space at approximately zero wind speed.
Figure 2: A human cough: saliva droplet’s disease-carrier particles emanating from coughing do not travel more than 2 m in space at approximately zero wind speed. The environment was considered to be at ambient temperature, pressure, and relative humidity of 20 oC, 1 atm and 50% with the ground temperature at 15 oC.
Figure 3: Saliva droplets can travel large distances, depending on environmental conditions such as wind speed, temperature, pressure and humidity.
Figure 3: Saliva droplets can travel large distances, depending on environmental conditions such as wind speed, temperature, pressure and humidity. Wind shown blowing left to right at speeds of 4 km/h (top) and 15 km/h (bottom) can transport saliva droplets up to 6 metres. The droplets in the figure have been scaled up for visualisation purposes.

Dbouk, T. and Drikakis, D. On coughing and airborne droplet transmission to humans. Physics of Fluids 32, 053310 (2020), published online 19 May 2020. doi.org/10.1063/5.0011960

What Does This Mean?

  1. In open spaces, airborne droplet carriers can travel significantly further than the 2m recommended distance depending on the wind speed and the environmental conditions. The above is an important finding and Citizens and policy-makers should be aware of it.
  2. If a person is in the path of the virus cloud, the risk of infection will, most likely, depend on the dosage and time of exposure. Therefore, it is crucial to better understand which scenarios may allow the transmission at longer distances. The present study contributes to advancing the above understanding.
  3. The dosage and time needed for an infection is still under study and may vary from one person to another. Further research and closer interaction between bio-medicine and engineering fluid physics are necessary to understand the conditions under which patients are being infected.

Videos

The simulations published with the paper. Each opens as a video file in the browser.

Non-Technical Summary

When sneezing or coughing, larger droplets are formed by saliva, and smaller droplets by mucous coating of the lungs and vocal cords. The smaller droplets are often invisible to the naked eye. Past research has shown that most respiratory droplets do not travel independently on their trajectories. Instead, droplets in a continuum of sizes are trapped and carried forward within a moist, warm, turbulent cloud of air. Although the mechanisms of virus transmission are still under debate, it is widely accepted that aerosol or respiratory droplet transmission is the critical factor for the rapid spread and continued circulation of viruses in humans.

We think that it is likely the dosage and time of exposure which determine whether or not infection will finally occur. Therefore, it is crucial to decide on the scenarios that will allow the transmission to longer distances. Our study aimed at advancing the understanding of the transfer of airborne particle carriers to humans through advanced coupling between droplets and fluid flow modelling and simulation.

The initial modelling configuration of the problem takes into account several parameters that can influence the simulation, including the wind speed in an open environment.

An accurate prediction of the transfer of airborne particle carriers to humans from a cough is governed by the following modelling considerations that must be taken into account:

  • The saliva droplets initial size distribution at the onset of the coughing event.
  • The human mouth-print of the cough.
  • The period of the cough and its intensity (or initial saliva droplets speed).
  • The numerical modelling approach to capture the complex varying space and time scales, e.g. both heat and mass transfer considerations, modelling of mass and phase changes due to droplets evaporation, coalescence, break up and turbulent dispersion in interaction with the bulk flow field.

The computational domain in the simulation is a grid in front of the coughing person . The analysis involved running partial differential equations on 1008 saliva droplets and solving approximately 3.7 million equations in total.

Our findings showed that, when a person coughs, the wind speed in an open space environment significantly influences the distance that airborne disease-carrier droplets travel.

  • Without surrounding wind speed, the droplets will fall to the ground in a short distance from the person exhaling or coughing. The present analysis shows that the range may not exceed one metre (See Figure 2). A tiny number of particles may travel slightly further longer. Still, their trajectory beyond one metre will already be at a height significantly below half a metre dropping towards the ground. Thus, these droplets may not constitute a risk regarding facial contact of adults at this distance.
  • At wind speeds from 4 to 15 km/h, we found that saliva droplets can travel to distances up to 6 metres with decreasing concentrations and liquid droplets size in the wind direction (see Figure 2). Our findings imply that depending on the environmental conditions, the 2 metres social distance may not suffice. Further research is required to quantify the influence of other parameters such as the environment relative humidity and temperature amongst others.
  • The droplets cloud will affect both adults and children of different heights. Shorter adults and children could be at higher risk if they are located within the trajectory of falling droplets.
  • At a lower wind speed, the droplet total mass reduction occurs more slowly compared to a higher speed, which may prolong the exposure of a human to the droplets if the subject is located within the droplets envelope.

Overall, the results showed that in open spaces, airborne droplets carriers can travel significantly further than the 2 metres recommended distance due to the wind speed. The issues arising from the past and recent pandemic require a holistic approach to elucidate the open scientific questions and address the practical challenges. Such an approach would require closer interaction between bio-medicine, engineering fluid physics, and social sciences.

UNIC’s COVID-19 Response

During the pandemic, University of Nicosia faculty across a range of academic disciplines worked on research and analysis, and served in scientific and public policy roles supporting the COVID-19 response.

The university’s other COVID-19 research is gathered on COVID-19 Research.

Contact Information

For more information about this study, contact Professor Dimitris Drikakis at drikakis.d@unic.ac.cy.